IL05: Library Blogs — Ethics & Guidelines

Karen G, Schneider, Director, Librarian’s Internet Index

  • Why ethics matter (micro)
    • [M: I lost this bit]
  • Why ethics matter (macro)
    • The harder we work to make the world a moral place, the better it is for everyone
    • “books are for use”: we are a profession defined by our concerns for others
  • rules to blog by
    • Transparancy
    • Fairness
    • Cite it
    • Get it right
    • Be Fair
    • Admit Mistakes
  • Two other codes of ethics
    • Rebecca Blood
      • Only facts you believe to be true
      • Link to it
    • Cyberjournalist.net
      • Be honest & fair
      • Minimize harm
      • Be accountable
  • 5 things not to say
    • It’s only a blog
    • So and so does it
    • Everyone understood what I menat
    • They can always look it up
    • Nobody trusts the web anyway
  • Define: Transparancy
    • “An activity is transparent if all information about it is open and freely available”
    • “For most blogs, we want to know what the writer’s starting point is.”
  • Transparence tools
  • The blogosphere is skeptical
    • Jeff Gannon
    • Claimed to be a White House correspondent
  • Transparency tools
    • A clear about page
      • Can be humorous
      • Must be true
    • Full disclosure about conflicts, biases or vested interests
    • A commitment to honest about who you are and what drives your writing
  • Lack of transparency can catch up with you
    • Don’t try to be something your not, they will find you out
  • Transparency can be Strategic
    • Groklaw
  • Transparency minimized Fisking
    • The act of critiquing in detail with intent of challenging its conclusion or theses by highlighting logical fallacies and incorrect facts
    • Memogate
  • Cite It
    • Michael Gorman
    • “Revenge of the Blog People”
  • Tips for good citations
    • Link to and name your sources
    • Avoid anonymous sources
    • Always check a secondary source
  • Get it Right
    • Judy Miller, NY Times
    • “The quality of being near to the true value”
    • “Investigative reporting is not stenography”
    • Being Wrong has Consequences
    • “There is nothing more pathetic than a librarian who gets the facts wrong”
  • How to get it right
    • Check your facts
    • Check your facts
    • Check your facts
    • Check your facts
    • don’t publish until you check your facts
    • re-check your facts after you publish
  • Tips for accuracy
    • dual source
    • link to your sources
  • Be Fair
    • Bill O’Reiley
  • Define: fairness
    • “the attitude of being just to all”
    • “giving people an equal chance”
    • “not letting partialit stand int he way of what is right”
  • Fairness Tips
    • let a source know when he is “on the record”
    • you can be opinioniated but don’t present opinion as fact
    • if you claim to be objective, then you better damn well present all sides of hte issue
    • let your readers comment (within reason)
  • Adimt Mistakes
    • Bill Clinton
  • define: mistake
    • “to choose wrongly”
    • a mistake can be an error of judgement or fact
  • Addressing mistakes in blogs
    • be direct, alert your readers
    • add to or modify posts
    • explain the mistake and the correction
  • Ethics Exception
    • the intentionally unreliable narrator
      • justinland.typepad.com
    • April Foolery
      • RFID Implats: The New Library Cards
    • Well-KNown Humor Sites
      • The Onion
  • When in doubt, Do what you know to be right
Posted in 1Tagged

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *